Skip to main content
Home
Muslim-Investor.com
Resources on Islamic Investment, Banking, Finance and Insurance
  • About
  • FAQ
  • Advertise
  • Forums
  • Site Map
  • Contact

Arabian Business: Over the hedge? Islamic Hedge Funds

  1. Home

Sun, 2007/06/17 - 11:44 by Muslim Investor

The move by Dubai Islamic Bank (DIB) last week to launch a Sharia-compliant investment fund linked to the performance of non-Sharia-compliant hedge funds has sparked controversy within the Islamic finance industry.

Created in partnership with two of the world's biggest financial institutions, Deutsche Bank and Goldman Sachs, the DIB fund aims to tap into the huge investment potential of conventional hedge funds, but still abide by Islamic law.

No money is actually invested directly in conventional hedge funds. Through what DIB describes as a "Sharia-compliant mechanism", the bank's fund is benchmarked against an index that measures the performance of a group of hedge funds. DIB's attempt to open up conventional hedge funds to Islamic investors, however, has met with criticism from a leading scholar in the industry.

Sharia advisor and Islamic scholar Yusuf Talal DeLorenzo has lambasted the fund, claiming that just because money is not being directly invested, it does not make the fund Sharia-compliant.

"It is a sad day for Islamic finance when an industry leader falls victim to the mistaken notion that just because a Muslim customer's money will never go into a potentially non-Sharia-compliant investment, the returns to the customer will actually be halal," DeLorenzo, chief Sharia officer at Shariah Capital, tells Arabian Business.

"Equally saddening is the notion that because the Muslim's investment returns will ‘reflect the performance' of funds that operate in a non-Sharia-compliant manner, and which invest in non-Sharia-compliant stocks, those returns can somehow be made lawful; as if the reflection of unlawful performance somehow differs from actual performance," he adds.

"It is one thing if an investment ‘reflects' a prohibited transaction in terms of its characteristics. It is another matter entirely, however, if an investment ‘reflects' a prohibited transaction by actually having its returns determined by that transaction," DeLorenzo argues.

Full article on Arabian Business.

  • Log in to post comments

User login

  • Reset password

Site map

Main menu

  • About
  • FAQ
  • Advertise
  • Forums
  • Site Map
  • Contact

Contents

  • Introduction
  • Basics
  • Principles
  • Scholar Answers
  • Stocks
  • Resources
    • General
    • Directories
    • Fatwas
    • Institutions
    • Education
    • Research
    • Books
    • Law Firms
    • Miscellaneous
  • Miscellany

Forums

  • Discussions
    • Investment
    • Financing
    • Banking
    • Insurance
    • Investment Scams
  • Site Related
    • Site Questions and Support

Scholar Answers

  • Bio - Yusuf Talal DeLorenzo
  • Shariah Screening
  • Mortgage on Investment properties
  • The Residual Value of Leased Assets
  • 401K Plan
more

Search

Book navigation

  • FAQ: Frequently Asked Questions

Venture Capital

  • FINANCE REQUIRED TO REBUILD INDIA & GCC
  • Instructions for Venture Capital Opportunities
  • hms 1/2 and used rails for sale
  • seeking investors for a franchise business in Indonesia
  • Need a investor to start business in maldives
more

© Copyright 1999-2025 Muslim-Investor.com.
All rights reserved.
All comments and articles by others are copyright by their owner, and reflect their views and opinions, which may not necessarily be consistent with the views and opinions of Muslim-Investor.com.
Please read our Terms of Use, and Privacy policy before you register for an account or post any information.